We all have opinions. I certainly do.
And over the years, I’ve had to remind myself that having an opinion and adding value aren’t necessarily the same thing.
It’s incredibly easy to criticize. We can criticize a decision, a policy, a strategy, a technique, an idea, or the way someone chooses to handle a situation. We can look at the finished product and quickly identify everything we would have done differently. Criticism requires very little investment. Contribution requires much more.
Before offering criticism, I think there are a few questions worth asking ourselves:
Am I being constructive? Do I have enough context to understand the bigger picture? What am I hoping to accomplish by sharing my opinion? And perhaps most importantly, do I have an idea that might actually make the situation better?
There is an important distinction here. I’m not suggesting that we shouldn’t challenge ideas or disagree with decisions. Quite the opposite. Healthy organizations need people who are willing to speak up. Some of the best decisions I’ve been part of came after someone respectfully challenged the original thinking.
But there’s a difference between saying, “Here’s what’s wrong with this,” and saying, “Here’s something I think could make this better.”
One points at the problem. The other takes some ownership in solving it.
The people whose opinions I’ve learned to value most aren’t necessarily the people who agree with me. In fact, sometimes they’re the ones who disagree. But when they do, they come with perspective, curiosity, respect, and, whenever possible, an alternative. Their goal isn’t to demonstrate that someone else is wrong. Their goal is to help us arrive at something better.
That’s constructive criticism, and there’s tremendous value in it.
The next time any of us feels the urge to criticize something, maybe the challenge is simply to pause long enough to ask:
Am I just identifying a problem, or am I willing to be part of the solution?
There will never be a shortage of critics.
Contributors are much harder to find.
Be a contributor.
TERRY Talks 